Jump directly to the content
pep suffers ed ache

Manchester City 0 Manchester United 2: Ederson has nightmare debut and is already being compared to flop Claudio Bravo

Keeper's blunder allowed Romelu Lukaku to net opener as rivals met in pre-season clash

MANCHESTER CITY new-boy Ederson is already being compared to flop Claudio Bravo after a nightmare debut.

The Brazilian stopper's blunder allowed Romelu Lukaku to score the opener as Manchester United beat the Citizens 2-0 in Houston.

 Ederson is beaten to the ball by Romelu Lukaku after rushing out of his area
9
Ederson is beaten to the ball by Romelu Lukaku after rushing out of his areaCredit: AP:Associated Press
 Lukaku was able to roll in his second United goal by the blunder
9
Lukaku was able to roll in his second United goal by the blunderCredit: AP:Associated Press

Lukaku beat the onrushing stopper to a ball outside the area and was able to roll into an empty net.

And after Joe Hart replacement Bravo also endured a dodgy debut against their Manchester rivals, City fans are getting a sense of deja vu.

United supporters were quick to gloat on Twitter as the £35million signing ensured Pep Guardiola's choice of goalkeeper will remain a contentious issue next season.

Many are asking if the Spaniard would have been better sticking with England No1 Hart, who saw his exile extended after joining West Ham on loan.

City are having to pay the outcast £55,000 per week for the duration of the season-long deal.

And combined with Ederson's fee and wages, getting a solid man between the sticks is proving to be a very expensive headache for Guardiola.

9
Credit: Twitter @IconicUnited
9

Bravo suffered similar humiliation at the start of last season as he fumbled a Wayne Rooney free-kick - allowing Zlatan Ibrahimovic to score.

City were 2-0 up at the time and held on to beat their rivals but their Chilean stopper never recovered.

After the match Gary Neville quipped: "Well, you can pass the ball but can you catch it?"

 Teen star Marcus Rashford fires home United's second
9
Teen star Marcus Rashford fires home United's secondCredit: Getty Images
 Claudio bravo had a debut to forget against Manchester United - fumbling to allow Zlatan Ibrahimovic to net
9
Claudio bravo had a debut to forget against Manchester United - fumbling to allow Zlatan Ibrahimovic to netCredit: Getty Images
 Bravo never recovered from his poor start and was roundly mocked by rival fans
9
Bravo never recovered from his poor start and was roundly mocked by rival fansCredit: EPA
 Ederson will need to bounce back against Real Madrid
9
Ederson will need to bounce back against Real MadridCredit: Getty Images
 Joe Hart could be forgiven for wondering why he was deemed surplus to requirements
9
Joe Hart could be forgiven for wondering why he was deemed surplus to requirementsCredit: PA:Press Association

City face Real Madrid on July 26 in another testing clash and Guardiola will be desperate for his new stopper to settle.

The Citizens will also face Tottenham and West Ham in friendlies before beginning their Premier League campaign at newly-promoted Brighton on August 12.


Keep up-to-date with all the latest transfer news and gossip in our live blog


Topics