Liverpool were forced to settle for a point on their return to the Champions League after blowing a 2-1 lead against Sevilla.
The Reds got off to a nightmare start when Wissam Ben Yedder pounced on an error by Dejan Lovren to put the visitors ahead.
But goals from Roberto Firmino and Mo Salah put Liverpool in charge, before Brazilian Firmino struck the post with a penalty.
That miss proved costly as Joaquin Correa sealed a point for Sevilla, before Joe Gomez was sent off late in the piece.
Here are the full player ratings from our man at Anfield, David Maddock...
Karius 6
Looked assured in his kicking and distribution, which was reason he was in the team
Gomez 6
Sent off. Good early strength and showed real purpose down right flank, solid defending before he was dismissed late on
Matip 6
Side’s outlet at the back, passing was always with intent, and showed strength too
Lovren 5
Awful mistake for early goal conceded, which knocked his confidence, but grew
Moreno 7
Booked. Brilliant for the important leveller in first half and almost scored on half time
Wijnaldum 7
Running impressive from deep and was a threat with his late unmarked bursts
Henderson 7
Showed real purpose going forward, influential in the middle and creative too
Can 6
Great on ball, missed big chance in first half, but still got forward well around box
Salah 8
Pace electric and real handful so many times for Sevilla, deserved goal if a fluke
Firmino 7
Looked back to creative best after City struggle, missed penalty will play on his mind
Mane 8 (MOM)
Such a massive outlet and such a threatening player at present, Sevilla had no answer