Ryan Giggs admits he would have started Butland over Hart

Casemiro opens up on why he nearly CANCELLED his £70m move to Man United from Real Madrid... as the Brazilian star reveals an emotional chat with Carlo Ancelotti almost changed his mind
Ratcliffe's revolution continues! Man United confirm appointment of Jason Wilcox as new technical director after agreeing compensation with Southampton and will start new role with immediate effect
Cole Palmer was asking to leave Man City for TWO seasons, reveals Pep Guardiola... as he admits he 'didn't give the Chelsea star the minutes he deserved'
PHIL FODEN on the very personal reason why he wears No 47, how he deals with the relentless Pep Guardiola... and he finally settles a Man City myth
Arsenal's April curse strikes again! SAMI MOKBEL reveals exactly what needs to change for Mikel Arteta to win major honours
Can Chelsea pile more misery on Man City and end their double hopes? The Blues are 12/5 to win FA Cup semi-final tie... with Cole Palmer 2/1 to score anytime against his former side
Man United target names the Red Devils as a club he'd love to play for, despite snubbing Erik ten Hag's advances for TWO YEARS... with Premier League rivals also on his list
Lower-league clubs could BOYCOTT the FA Cup in fury after the Premier League and The FA agreed to scrap replays in the hallowed tournament
Michael Schumacher's incredible watch collection 'is set to be auctioned by his family' with eight of his unique timepieces 'expected to fetch an estimated £5M'
Tired? Give it a rest. If Man City keep talking about feeling jaded then they'll start to believe they are, writes GRAEME SOUNESS
Coventry have been penniless, homeless and at war with their owners but, like the city bombed in 1940, they have risen from the rubble to set up their semi-final date with Man United
Richard Keys claims Jurgen Klopp has 'KILLED' Liverpool with 'ill-judged' mid-season announcement about leaving, as Reds' campaign unravels ahead of his summer exit
Man City 'are already preparing for life after Pep Guardiola and have identified LaLiga boss as a potential successor to the Spaniard when he leaves the Etihad'
New footage shows Xabi Alonso and his Bayer Leverkusen staff reacting to finding out Europa League semi-final opponent, as footage prompts fans to warn German champions about underestimating Roma
Newcastle star Bruno Guimaraes hints he will STAY at the club after splashing £4MILLION on house in the North East - as Premier League rivals prepare to tempt Brazil star away from Tyneside
Unai Emery hails Emiliano Martinez as the 'BEST goalkeeper in the world' after match-winning display and antics against Lille, but admits he 'thought Argentine would be sent off'
Bayern Munich are 'one step away' from appointing Zinedine Zidane as manager... with Frenchman also monitoring managerial situation at Manchester United
Emma Raducanu LOSES to world No 1 Iga Swiatek in straight sets in quarter-finals of the Stuttgart Open.. as her winless run against top-10 players drags on
Not since Diego Maradona have Argentina had a pantomime villain to match wind-up merchant Emiliano Martinez... but his £16m move to Aston Villa is one of Arsenal's daftest decisions
Chelsea 'are set to rival Man City for Jamal Musiala' as Blues look to bring former youth star back to England after starring for Bayern Munich
Emma Hayes insists she isn't thinking of a fairytale Chelsea ending as Blues target Champions League glory against 'world class' Barcelona
Jack Grealish issues rallying cry after Champions League penalty heartbreak and insists 'tiredness is in the mind' as Man City face FA Cup showdown with Chelsea
Barcelona legend urges the club to hire Jose Mourinho to replace Xavi despite history managing rivals Real Madrid... as he explains why he would be a 'great signing 'at the Nou Camp
Does anyone want promotion to the Premier League?! Leicester fans have fallen out of love with Enzo Maresca and the heat is on Southampton boss Russell Martin as rivals stumble in Championship run-in

Ryan Giggs believes Gareth Southgate should have started Jack Butland
Giggs claimed Southgate would have learned more from dropping Joe Hart
He admitted if the decision was his he would have started Butland over Hart
Southgate said Hart is his No 1 but admitted there is competition for his place

Published: 14:56 EDT, 1 September 2017 | Updated: 15:32 EDT, 1 September 2017

e-mail

173

View
comments

Former Manchester United and Wales winger Ryan Giggs admits he would have opted to start Jack Butland in goal for England's World Cup qualifier against Malta.

England boss Gareth Southgate had faced a selection headache over who would be his No 1, particularly after Joe Hart's poor start to the Premier League season.

But Southgate insisted on Thursday Hart remains his first choice keeper despite fierce competition from Jordan Pickford and Butland.

Ryan Giggs admitted he would have started Jack Butland in goal over Joe Hart for Malta clash

Giggs admitted prior to kick-off, if the decision were his to make he would have given Butland the nod over Hart.

He said: 'It depends how the season goes for Pickford, Butland and Hart.

'Personally I would have played Butland. You don't want to be chopping and changing your goalkeeper but what is he going to learn from playing Hart?

'You know that he can miss a few games and then come in and he's got the experience to do what he does.

Gareth Southgate named Butland on the bench for the World Cup qualifier against Malta

'So I would've (gone with Butland), especially in a game like this when you're not going to see a lot of action.'

He added: 'In previous years he hasn't been looking over his shoulder but now he's got two up and coming goalkeepers who can be No 1 for England'

Hart, who has conceded 10 goals in just three Premier League games this season, has won 71 international caps and has been England's first choice between the sticks for several years.

But now faces stiff competition with both Pickford and Butland vying for his spot.